book review: Under the Cover of Mercy

Under the Cover of Mercy by Rebecca Connolly is a work of historical fiction set in Belgium during World War I. I have read many books set during World War II, but I believe this is my first set during the earlier war. It is the captivating story of a courageous group of nurses. I’m happy to give a five-star book review of Under the Cover of Mercy.

Book summary:

Under the Cover of Mercy by Rebecca Connolly is a historical novel set during the tumultuous period of World War I. It tells the compelling story of Edith Cavell, a British nurse who courageously helped hundreds of Allied soldiers escape from occupied Belgium.

The novel delves into Edith’s life, her deep sense of duty, and her unwavering commitment to humanity, even at great personal risk. Working as a nurse, she not only provides care for the wounded but also secretly organizes escape routes for soldiers, defying German occupation forces.

Rebecca Connolly brings to life the moral struggles and the bravery of Cavell, who becomes a symbol of mercy and sacrifice. The book also explores themes of compassion, the ethics of war, and the impact of individual courage in the face of overwhelming odds. Under the Cover of Mercy is both a tribute to a historical figure and a gripping narrative about the strength of the human spirit.

---

Significant characters in Under the Cover of Mercy by Rebecca Connolly:

Edith Cavell

The protagonist of the story, Edith is a British nurse working in German-occupied Belgium during World War I. She is compassionate, principled, and fiercely dedicated to helping others. Edith’s bravery in aiding hundreds of Allied soldiers and organizing escape routes makes her a symbol of mercy and sacrifice. She is remembered as a heroine for her courage and selflessness.

Dr. Antoine Depage

A Belgian doctor and the head of the nursing school where Edith works. He is instrumental in training nurses and running the medical facility in Brussels. His close professional relationship with Edith plays a vital role in her ability to assist Allied soldiers. Dr. Depage is a strong and respected figure who shares Edith’s commitment to helping the wounded, regardless of their nationality.

Marie Depage

The wife of Dr. Antoine Depage, Marie is a humanitarian who works closely with Edith in the hospital. She shares Edith’s ideals and supports her efforts to aid Allied soldiers. Marie’s character adds depth to the sense of community and shared sacrifice during the war.

Philippe Baucq

A key member of the underground network that helps Edith smuggle soldiers out of Belgium. He works as a Belgian architect, but during the war he becomes a brave and resourceful figure in the resistance. Philippe’s collaboration with Edith is essential in orchestrating the escape efforts. His fate becomes intertwined with hers as they both face the consequences of their actions.

Elizabeth Wilkins

One of Edith’s fellow nurses and confidantes. She assists in the hospital and, at times, helps with the secret operations Edith organizes. Elizabeth is loyal to Edith and shares in the danger, demonstrating the strong bond between the nurses in the midst of war.

Jean Wauters

A young Belgian man who becomes involved in the network Edith helps run. His character shows the impact of Edith’s influence on the local Belgian population and their willingness to join in the resistance effort.

These characters each highlight Edith’s personal journey and the broader wartime resistance. Edith, the Depages, and Phillipe Baucq were real people. Elizabeth Wilkins was indeed a nurse working with Edith, but the author combined elements of many nurses into a smaller number to simplify the story. Some aspects of her character may have come from accounts of other nurses. Jean Wauters appears to be a fictional character, used to represent the many Belgian citizens who were involved in the resistance efforts.

---

Under the Cover of Mercy by Rebecca Connolly explores many themes:

Sacrifice and duty

The theme of sacrifice is central to the novel, embodied in the character of Edith Cavell, who chooses to risk her life for the greater good. Cavell’s duty as a nurse transcends national loyalties. Her decision to help soldiers escape is driven by her deep moral conviction to save lives, regardless of their nationality. The book explores the personal cost of this sacrifice. This theme invites readers to reflect on what it means to follow a sense of duty, even when it leads to dire consequences.

Compassion in wartime

Compassion is another crucial theme in the story. Edith Cavell’s care for wounded soldiers and her willingness to put herself in danger to help them demonstrate the power of empathy in the face of violence. Her work at the hospital and her involvement in the underground resistance illustrate how acts of kindness and mercy can flourish even in the darkest times of war. The novel emphasizes that compassion is not limited by borders, with Cavell treating both Allied and enemy soldiers.

Moral courage

Edith’s actions throughout the novel highlight the theme of moral courage. Faced with the oppressive occupation of Belgium by German forces, Cavell refuses to be cowed by fear or threats. Her defiance is not rooted in rebellion but in a steadfast adherence to her principles. The novel examines how moral courage can inspire others and the price one often pays for standing up for what is right.

Ethics of war

The novel explores the ethical dilemmas presented by war. Edith Cavell’s decision to help soldiers escape raises questions about the fine line between humanitarianism and espionage. The German authorities view her actions as aiding the enemy, while Edith sees them as saving lives. This theme provokes thought about the nature of right and wrong in wartime, when traditional moral boundaries are often blurred. It challenges readers to consider the complexities of ethical decision-making in times of conflict.

The role of women in war

The novel also touches on the evolving role of women in wartime, as exemplified by Edith Cavell and her colleagues like Marie Depage. These women are not passive bystanders; they take on critical roles in healthcare and resistance efforts. The novel portrays their strength, independence, and leadership during a time when women’s contributions were often undervalued. This theme highlights the important yet often overlooked roles women played in shaping the course of history during World War I.

Faith and conviction

Faith is a quiet but persistent theme in Under the Cover of Mercy by Rebecca Connolly. Edith Cavell’s Christian beliefs deeply influence her sense of duty and mercy, guiding her actions throughout the novel. Her faith provides her with the inner strength to remain resolute in the face of persecution. Her trust in a higher moral law than the one enforced by the Germans offers her peace. The novel portrays how personal convictions rooted in faith can shape moral decisions and give individuals courage.

The power of resistance

Another important theme is the power of resistance, both overt and subtle. The characters involved in the underground network represent how individuals can resist tyranny in different ways. Edith’s resistance is non-violent, using her position as a nurse to shelter and aid soldiers. Figures like Philippe Baucq are more directly involved in organizing the resistance efforts. Even small acts of defiance can have significant impacts, and resistance to injustice is both a moral and collective responsibility.

The novel is both a historical narrative and a meditation on compassion, courage, and humanity in times of crisis.

---

Suggested book club discussion questions

My book review of Under the Cover of Mercy by Rebecca Connolly wouldn’t be complete without a few discussion questions. Especially considering my book club decided to read it! Additional questions are found at the end of the book along with interesting notes from the author.

Here are a few questions to ponder:

• Character development: How do you see Edith Cavell evolving throughout the story? What are the key events that shape her character and motivations?
• Historical context: How does the author portray the tension and challenges brought about by World War I? What did you learn about the historical period?
• Nursing and compassion: Edith Cavell was a nurse who helped soldiers from both sides of the war. How does this act of mercy reflect in the title and the themes of the book?
• Moral dilemmas: Edith faces several moral decisions throughout the novel. Were there any choices she made that you found difficult to accept or understand? How might you have handled similar situations?
• Secondary characters: How do the secondary characters, such as those working with Edith, contribute to the overall narrative? Are there any characters who stood out to you?
• Faith and courage: Edith’s faith is a central element in her life. How does it guide her decisions, especially when faced with danger?
• Legacy: After reading the book, what do you think Edith’s legacy is? How has the author helped bring her story to life in a way that resonates with modern readers?
• Emotional impact: Which parts of the novel had the most emotional impact on you? Why?
• Title reflection: Reflect on the title Under the Cover of Mercy. What layers of meaning does it have after reading the book?

A note about poppies, which are pictured at the top of this post and on the book cover

Red poppies symbolize remembrance of soldiers who died in wars, especially in World War I. This association comes from the famous poem “In Flanders Fields” by John McCrae. In many countries, red poppies are worn around Remembrance Day or Veterans Day.

I enthusiastically offer my five-star book review of Under the Cover of Mercy. Author Rebecca Connolly beautifully expressed many emotional scenes.

Let me know what you think if you read it. Have you read any other WWI historical fiction? If you would like more information about author Rebecca Connolly, check out my feature of her at this link. I’ve also reviewed other books of hers: Hidden Yellow Stars (WWII) and A Brilliant Night of Stars and Ice (about the Titanic).

Other posts you may enjoy:

• prayer guide for our elections: seeking God’s wisdom and peace
• The Mystic Jesus by Marianne Williamson: book club discussion
• Tofu lasagna for the win!
• breath prayer: inhale peace and exhale stress

Fondly,

Crysti